Your boss says: Challenge my ideas. Then you do, and the temperature drops. Most people learn from that moment to stay quiet, and the organisation loses its best corrective.
In 2021, Forbes asked 15 members of its Coaches Council how to offer a differing opinion in a way the boss will value. I was one of them. Here are the 15 ways as I read them today, because shared leadership only works where disagreement is survivable.
Acknowledge the leader's idea as one option, then ask: "I wonder what would happen if X?" Pushing straight against the idea puts the leader on the defensive, and then it's about being right. A question invites them into problem-solving with you and keeps emotions in check.
Origin: Cindy Barber, The Dash Group
Nobody likes surprises at work, bosses least of all. Bring hints: Data and papers from credible sources that point to a different path. Watch the reaction. If it's open, set up a conversation and arrive with a short deck, numbers and sources that show the business effect.
Origin: Lauren Cooney, Spark Labs
Countering a senior's conclusion with another conclusion is risky. Countering it with a question that opens a deeper insight, or exposes a hole in the reasoning, creates possibilities nobody had seen. You become a high-value ally instead of an adversary.
Origin: April Armstrong, AHA Insight
Avoid accusatory wording. Ask: "Have you considered X?" or "Mind if I offer a completely different idea?" If you're going to say no to an idea, always bring a counter-idea. Never run into a burning building shouting "fire" without carrying a hose.
Origin: Jen Croneberger, JLynne Consulting Group
Open by tying your proposal to the vision and goals the leader already owns, and back it with data. An opinion that has matured through data, fit and clear communication has a far better chance of being heard.
Origin: Bree Luther, Inspired Science Coaching
Check in directly: How would you like to be challenged? First, that shows whether the leader means it or is paying lip service. Second, you learn in which settings and under which conditions disagreement works for them. That sets you up for the moment you need it.
Origin: Palena Neale, unabridged
Let them know you see it differently. Disagreement rejects an idea, never the person. Gather facts, explain your idea, share the vision and the results, and be persuasive about the benefits. A solidly explained idea gets entertained.
Origin: Debra Kasowski, Debra Kasowski International
Don't be shy. Offer your opinion and back it with numbers. Build the business case and tell the story of why your idea leads to better outcomes. It may be something the leader never considered. And know your audience: Choose the way of saying it that lands as constructive.
Origin: Annette Franz, CX Journey
Lead from the wish to reach an outcome that's good for both, no winners and losers. Small behaviours carry that message: Confident eye contact where culturally appropriate, "I" statements instead of "you", and clarifying questions that show you listened before you disagreed.
Origin: Mark Batson Baril, Resologics
Acknowledge the idea, then build on it. "I hear your proposed solution, and…" The word "and" instead of "but" tells the leader you're adding to their thinking rather than tearing it down. After the "and", introduce your own idea.
Origin: Kirsten Meneghello, Illumination Coaching
Make clear that your intent is a different view, and that you respect their position. That keeps the leader secure and keeps them from getting defensive while you talk. Dissent that's mistaken for disrespect ends the conversation. Dissent with respect starts one.
Origin: Jonathan Silk, Bridge 3
Is it the right time and place? Your self-awareness is the first key. You can challenge any idea with courage, respect and an open mind, as long as ego isn't driving. In a toxic or political environment, candour can backfire badly. Read the room before you speak in it.
Origin: Jon Michail, Image Group International
Every idea has parts. Some you disagree with, others match your thinking. Start with the common ground: Maybe the discount is right and the timing is off. Maybe the process is sound and the staff needs retraining. Then support your view with evidence and business benefits.
Origin: Gabriella Goddard, Brainsparker Leadership Academy
One panellist coaches a leader who wants his team to challenge him, and they don't do it at the level he wants. Her suggestion: Start with "May I challenge your thinking on that?" or "That's one idea. May I share another?" Asking breaks the ice, and the idea gets received.
Origin: Michelle Braden, MSBCoach
This one is mine, and I'd write it the same way today. Speak loudly and clearly enough, with a confident tone, and take the time to form your thoughts. Quiet people are often half-listened to, and rarely because they speak too softly. Their whole posture says they're probably not worth hearing. Confidence is good. A loud, bossy manner is something else.
Origin: Cristian Hofmann, Empowering Executives, SUPERGROUP AG
Thirteen of the 15 ways are about the first 10 seconds: How you open. Curiosity, permission, common ground, "and" instead of "but". The content of your objection matters less than the frame you put around it.
Whether every boss who asks for challenge can take it, I doubt it. Point 6 tests that cheaply. In my work with leadership teams, shared leadership stands or falls on this: Can the second-in-command say "I see it differently" in the meeting, and still be in the room next week?
Further reading on hofmann.coach: 14 communication mistakes the best leaders avoid · How CEOs can better keep stakeholders in the loop · Leadership Coaching
Note: The 15 ways come from the Forbes Coaches Council expert panel "15 Effective And Tactful Ways To Challenge The Boss's Idea", published 12 January 2021. Contribution no. 15 is my own. My reading of the other fourteen is mine, and it isn't a quote of my colleagues' wording.
Cristian Hofmann is an executive coach in Zurich and Schaffhausen (MAS Coaching & Supervision BSO, Forbes contributor). Over more than 20 years he has coached more than 1,500 leaders: CEOs, executive boards and leadership teams in Switzerland, with measurably agreed goals and, on request, pay-for-results. More about Cristian Hofmann.
This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. Learn more
